Likelihood of 2-player market increasing everyday, Telecom News, ET Telecom

After Merger With Vodafone Group, Idea Cellular Becomes ‘Vodafone Idea Limited’

New Delhi: ET spoke to Naveen Kulkarni, head of analysis at Reliance Securities concerning the Telecom trade and the upcoming 5G public sale.

Q. Give us your view of the Telecom trade as a complete.

Naveen Kulkarni: The trade is clearly a three-player construction now. The high three gamers, Vodafone Idea, Bharti Airtel and Jio – they’ve near 90% of income and market share. And clearly Jio is the one who’s gaining market share, Airtel is in some way in a position to handle its market share and Vodafone Idea have been dropping market share. This will proceed until Vodafone Idea are in a position to scale up their community high quality to a sure stage the place they cease dropping prospects or begin getting again prospects. The market proper now could be divided into smartphone customers and non-smartphone customers.

Q. Is it worth versus quantity?

Naveen: No that is not the case. Everything is a quantity play proper now. But there are prospects who pay the next RPU (income per person). Typically, these are postpaid customers. They had been actually sticky with the incumbents. I consider even they’ve began to maneuver out now.

Q. The trade has been fighting quite a bit of debt. Now that consolidation that has occurred, can we count on pricing to go up and profitability to return for incumbents?Naveen: Who is struggling? It’s Vodafone Idea and Bharti, fighting debt. Not a lot Jio.

Firstly, Jio has a far higher quantity of capability on the community than each the opponents put collectively. The second is that so long as they [Jio] maintain gaining market share, why would they need to change the pricing? If you cease gaining market share or if the market share good points begin to come down considerably, you then decrease the incremental quantity you’re investing within the type of advertising or some other side. There needs to be a reducing economies of scale, in keeping with their benchmarks. We have in all probability not reached that stage. They’re nonetheless gaining an enormous quantity of subscribers each month. It’s unlikely that they’ll enhance the worth within the instant time period.

It although can occur in a short time – in a 3-6 months’ timeframe. These inflection factors are anyone’s guess. Pricing is sure to maneuver up. In truth, pricing had moved up. Then from this January, costs began happening once more. Jio launched providers in 2016. In May 2017 we began seeing an enchancment in pricing, however in January once more the costs had been introduced down.

Q. Why was that the case?

Naveen: Since Bharti lower costs, Jio additionally lower costs. They needed to take care of a reduction from the main operators. If the incumbents lower costs, then they’ll lower costs additional.

Q. What’s your outlook on 5G? Is there urge for food for 5G?

Naveen: My sense is that there’s not a lot urge for food for 5G. That’s anyone’s guess until it will get launched. Will it get to be mainstream? I can’t say whether or not that would be the case. Technically it is a capability product, it is not a protection product.

4G is a protection in addition to capability product. 5G is just capability. You cannot use it for masking rural areas or highways. This is as a result of it operates on a a lot increased frequency band and the quantity of velocity that 5G talks about is one thing which isn’t required for the sort of purposes we use. 4G suffices for purposes like watching movies, et cetera. You would possibly want 5G play in central enterprise districts like BKC or Nariman Point or Andheri the place the inhabitants density and the quantity of smartphone customers could be very excessive.

There could be necessities for 5G in creating hotspots in railway stations and airports. But is it a mainstream play? There is a query mark on that.

Has anyone cracked a correct enterprise mannequin for 5G? No one has began earning money on 5G . 4G is a profitable enterprise mannequin. There are sufficient examples all over the world the place it’s a confirmed product. 5G remains to be some years away. Its utility is perhaps very completely different – extra for decent spots, enterprise districts and company use.

Frequency and wavelength are inversely proportional to one another. If you could have the next frequency, then the attenuation (power loss) is increased. The waves is not going to journey very far. On the opposite hand, the quantity of knowledge that may be transferred is increased on the next frequency band. India has by no means been a pure high quality play. It’s at all times been a protection play.

Q. In India, we lag behind on the subject of velocity – be it wi-fi or broadband. Could 5G fill on this area of interest – of individuals who need increased velocity?

There isn’t any simple reply to this query. We are usually not lagging behind as a result of of know-how. Quality will go up when pricing goes up. When costs go up, there are lesser prospects and high quality goes up.

Q. Can’t these two issues co-exist – high quality and worth?

It’s troublesome in wi-fi. You can have a a lot increased velocity and decrease tariffs in wi-fi, so long as there’s an RoI (return on funding). Wireless will at all times have a limitation in phrases of capability. That’s why you’ll be able to speak about 5G, however the place is the return on the capital? Nobody is earning money within the enterprise on the finish of the day. The trade put collectively is making losses. There are 4 gamers who’ve shut down. You can speak about 5G, however the place is the return on the capital? I do not know what the long run is. You can maintain investing, however folks aren’t paying. The trade was near Rs.2 lakh crore income in 2014. Now the trade is near Rs.1.2 lakh crore income. That’s down 40%. Investments have gone up by hundred p.c. How do you become profitable? When you take a look at the debt numbers, Bharti is at round Rs1 lakh crores. Idea Vodafone at round Rs1.2 lakh crore. We do not know the debt for Jio.

Q. Is there a restrict on 4G velocity that may be supplied?

There is a restrict to the velocity on each community. But it is not the velocity. It’s about what number of prospects you’ll be able to service, with a low error charge and what type of protection you’ll be able to provide.

There are a number of facets to a community – one is protection. The second is what does it value to get that protection. What will it take to ascertain a pan India 5G community? Let’s say round a 100 million {dollars}. Maybe extra?

Jio has a pan India 4G community. With the sort of capability that they’ve constructed, they’ve invested round Rs.3-3.5 lakh crore. If you double that quantity, triple or qudaruple that quantity, you may get a pan-India 5G community. You’re in all probability enhance the velocity you’re offering proper now on 4G by 5 occasions. That’s adequate velocity, however what’s it for? Who is it for?

And will we now have sufficient 5G-ready handsets by then?

Q. Could we be taking a look at a 2-player situation sooner or later?

Naveen: Everyday, the probability of that’s increasing. Unlike in banking, the place the federal government props up banks as a result of they’re too massive to fail, as a result of they’re systemically necessary, there’s no precedent for that in Telecom. If it turns into a 2-player situation, then costs are sure to maneuver up.

Leave a Reply